- He came up the porch steps. Two at a time. Bertram behind him.
- “What the hell are you doing here?” Thurston said. “This is private property. You don’t work here anymore. Carlton paid you off.”
- I looked at him.
- At his boots that had never seen a cow pasture. At his Range Rover. At his phone.
- “I just got a call,” Thurston said. “From my developer’s lawyer. In Franklin. He ran a title search. On the farm. For the closing. Next month.”
- His voice was shaking.
- “He says there’s a deed,” Thurston said. “Recorded in April. Thirty-eight acres. On the Pike. With the pecan grove.”
- He held up the phone.
- “He says it’s in your name,” he said.
- “Yes,” I said.
- Thurston stared at me.
- “That’s—that’s not possible,” he said. “Mother would never—that’s fraud. You did something. You got her to sign something. She was ninety-four. She didn’t know what she was doing.”
- Bertram was nodding behind him.
- “Undue influence,” Bertram said. “That’s what it’s called. We’ll take it to court. We’ll get it voided. Any judge in this county—”
- “She knew what she was doing,” a voice said.
- From the lane.
- We all turned.
- Carlton.
- Walking down the gravel. From the big house. In his gray sweater. Slow. His hands in his pockets.
- He’d been there the whole time. In the farmhouse. He must have seen the Range Rover tear down the lane.
- He walked up to the bottom of the porch steps.
- He stopped.
- He looked at his brothers.
- “She knew exactly what she was doing,” Carlton said. “I was there. I drove her to the courthouse. I carried her walker up the steps. I sat next to her while she signed it.”
- He looked up at me.
- “I witnessed it,” he said.
- Thurston turned around.
- “You?”
- “Me,” Carlton said.
- “You knew?” Thurston said. “Since April? And you let me sign a contract for the whole farm? In July?”
- “I told you not to sign it,” Carlton said quietly. “I told you to wait. You said, Mother’s ninety-four, she’ll be gone by Christmas, what’s the difference.”
- What’s the difference.
- Thurston’s face went white.
- “Patricia Odom has a video,” Carlton said. “Of Mother. Recorded the day before she signed. Forty-one minutes. A doctor from Vanderbilt examined her on camera. Asked her the date, the president, her children’s names, her birthday. Asked her what she was signing and why.”
- He looked at Bertram.
- “She answered every question,” Carlton said. “She did the crossword on camera. In ink.”
- “Then she told the whole story,” Carlton said. “Isaac Whitsett. The tax sale. Horace’s letter. Forty-two dollars on the courthouse steps.”
- He looked back at Thurston.
- “And at the end,” he said, “the lawyer asked her if anyone had pressured her. If Elnora had asked for this.”
- He looked up at me.
- “Mother laughed,” Carlton said. “She said, Elnora? Elnora has never asked anybody for anything in her whole life. That’s the problem.”
- Thurston and Bertram filed a lawsuit anyway.
- In October. In Maury County Chancery Court. Lockridge v. Whitsett.
- Undue influence. Lack of capacity. They wanted the deed set aside.
- Alfreda called me the day the papers came.
- “Mama,” she said. “I told you. I told you. They’re going to eat you alive.”
- “Maybe,” I said.
- “Mama, you need a lawyer. A real one. Those boys have three.”
- “I have one,” I said.
- Patricia Odom drove down from Nashville the next morning.
- She was fifty-five. Black. Short gray hair. A navy suit. Reading glasses on top of her head.
- She sat at my kitchen table on East End Street. Under the peach magnet.
- She opened her briefcase.
- “Mrs. Whitsett,” she said. “Henrietta Lockridge paid my retainer in full. In April. For any challenge to this deed. Through any appeal. All the way to the Tennessee Supreme Court if necessary.”
- She smiled.
- “She said, They’ll fight it, Patricia. Thurston will, anyway. Make sure Elnora never pays a dime.”
- The hearing was in January.
- The chancellor was a woman named Hon. Margaret Haynes Pruitt.
- Margaret Haynes’s daughter.
- Of the Tuesday bridge club.
- Thurston’s lawyer asked her to recuse herself.
- She declined.
- “Counselor,” she said. “Every judge in this county knew Henrietta Lockridge. If knowing her disqualified us, you’d have to try this case in Kentucky.”
- They played the video.
- All forty-one minutes.
- In the courtroom on the second floor of the Maury County Courthouse.
- Down the hall from where the water fountain used to be.
- I’d never seen it.
- Patricia asked me if I wanted to watch it first. In private. I said no.
- I wanted to see it there.
- There she was.
- On a TV screen on a cart. Sitting in her chair by the fire. In the sitting room. Her afghan over her knees. Her reading glasses on. A coffee cup in her hand. One of the good china ones. With the little blue flowers.
- Ninety-three years old.
- Sharp as a tack.
- The doctor from Vanderbilt asked her questions.
- She answered every one.
- What’s today’s date? April tenth. Who’s the president? Don’t get me started. What are your sons’ names? Carlton, Thurston, and Bertram. In order of how often they call.
- The courtroom laughed.
- Thurston didn’t.
- Then Patricia’s voice. Off camera.
- Mrs. Lockridge, can you tell us what you intend to sign tomorrow, and why?
- Mrs. Lockridge set down her coffee cup.
- She looked at the camera.
- I’m returning thirty-eight acres of land, she said, to a woman named Elnora Ruthanne Whitsett.
- That land belonged to her great-grandfather. Isaac Whitsett. He bought it with his own hands in 1879. He was born a slave on a plantation in Giles County. He walked out of it in 1865 with nothing but the clothes on his back. He worked fourteen years to buy that ground.
- My husband’s uncle stole it from him in 1931. With a forged tax bill and forty-two dollars.
- And the Whitsett family has been cleaning my family’s floors ever since.
- The courtroom was silent.
- Elnora’s mother worked for this family for forty-three years, Mrs. Lockridge said. For eleven dollars a week and a house she didn’t know her own grandfather once owned.
- Elnora has worked for me for twenty-six years. Every Monday. Every Thursday. Every Friday, I make her sit down and have coffee with me. Because it’s the only time all week anybody in this family sits down with her.
- She picked up her coffee cup.
- She looked at it.
PART 7